Dave Portnoy’s ‘One Bite Pizza Fest’ Will Feature These 10 New York Pizzerias

Have you ever met anyone that does not like pizza? I don't believe that person exists so here is an event everyone will like. Dave Portnoy's 'One Bite Pizza Fest' at New York's Randall's Island Park.

For those that believe New Yorkers make the best pizza in the world, this is your chance to compare a New York pie to our rivals in Connecticut, Philadelphia, New Jersey and beyond. Which New York pizzerias will be attending Dave Portnoy's 'One Bite Pizza Fest'? Let's take a look.

Get our free mobile app

Dave Portnoy's 'One Bite Pizza Fest' will take place at Randall's Island Park on Saturday September 13, 2025. Tickets for this event will go on sale Friday June 20th at 10am HERE. There are several different ticket options, and each ticket is all-you-can-eat.

This year's pizzeria lineup includes several Connecticut heavyweights such as New Haven's Frank Pepe (pictured below), Sally's and Modern. As a matter of fact 9 Connecticut pizzerias will be attending this years festival. Which ones from New York?

According to the One Bite Pizza Fest site, there are currently 10 New York Pizzerias scheduled to attend. Here they are along with their 'One Bite Pizza Review' score.

• Di Farra Pizza - Brooklyn - 9.4
• John's of Bleeker Street - Manhattan - 9.3
• Ceres - Manhattan - 9.3
• Lucali - Brooklyn - 9.3
• Luigi's Pizza - Brooklyn - 9.3

The One Bite Pizza Fest is an all ages event. Children under the age of 2 are free and for those 21-years-old and older there will be beer and liquor for sale.

• Prince Street Pizza - Manhattan - 8.6
• Joe & Pat's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Manhattan - 8.4
• Borelli's Restaurant - East Meadow, NY - 7.9
• Nona's - Brooklyn - 7.7
• East Village Pizza - Manhattan - 6.9